Sunday, July 12, 2009

Jane Jacobs Atlantic Yards Report Card #20: Avoidance of Harmful Gas Stations? MAYBE YES/MAYBE NO

This is evaluation item #20 (of 47) of the Jane Jacobs Atlantic Yards Report Card

Avoidance of Harmful Gas Stations? MAYBE YES/MAYBE NO

(Image from Atlantic Yards Report. Click to enlarge.)

Jane Jacobs suggested that gas stations in the wrong areas would deaden neighborhoods. Those looking for a positive accomplishment in the Atlantic Yards Development can point out that a gas station will be one of the condemned businesses. On the other hand, the gas station which sits on an island on busy Flatbush Avenue might be in about as good a place as it might ever be in terms of not disturbing an adjoining neighborhood. Arguably, on the other side, when it goes out of business at this location it is possible the demand for an unfilled service may result in a new gas station springing up in a less desirable location.

(Since this was originally written the gas station is gone: See above photo from Atlantic Yards Report. Instead you can go to the similar still remaining one below on Atlantic Avenue between Brooklyn Heights and Cobble Hill.)
JJ Cites: [. . . .Visually, they are disorganizing to streets, and so dominating that it is hard- - sometimes impossible– for any countering sense of order to make much impression. P. 234]

No comments: